© 2022 WNMU-FM
Upper Great Lakes News, Music, and Arts & Culture
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations

Birth mother of "Baby Garnet" charged with murder

Nancy Gerwatowski.JPG
Mackinac County Sheriff's Office

HUDSON TOWNSHIP, MI— A 58-year-old woman has been extradited from Wyoming to Mackinac County in connection with the death of a baby in 1997.

Police found the remains of an infant in a vault toilet at Garnet Lake Campground. The infant was nicknamed “Baby Garnet.”

The case went cold until 2017, when genetic genealogy led officials to the birth mother. She’s identified as Nancy Ann Gerwatowski—maiden name Niskala.

The Michigan State Police 7th District Fugitive Team brought Gerwatowski back to Michigan on July 30. She was arraigned Sunday on a charge of homicide-open murder. She remains lodged without bond in the Mackinac County Jail.

Gerwatowski’s next court appearance is set for Tuesday in Mackinac County District Court.

Nicole was born near Detroit but has lived in the U.P. most of her life. She graduated from Marquette Senior High School and attended Michigan State and Northern Michigan Universities, graduating from NMU in 1993 with a degree in English.